The new Star Trek movie sends shivers up your spine – the first scene has such a breathtaking velocity, it takes the wind out of you. “This is what cinema is for,” your correspondent felt, rooted to the spot. It eases back after that, and the plot is best left unsaid and unspoiled, but J.J. Abrams is to be applauded for taking real risks with a franchise that has often become trapped by its own canon. For the fans, canon is great – it gives them something to hash and rehash, a universe to live in – but it can be exclusive and limiting.
Every crew member has their chance to shine, but for News Hour the revelation was Karl Urban’s Dr McCoy. Urban does what at first seems to be an impression, and perhaps it is – but you believe him. He snarls and complains like a good ‘ol boy, paranoid but keen to do what’s right, offering some medicinal from a hip flask; him and Kirk are kindred spirits of a kind, but the movie’s narrative heart is in blending Kirk and Spock, and it’s the latter who has the emotional lead. Zachary Quinto is initially jarring in the role, but soon makes perfect sense. In some ways he is damaged by early scenes with young Spock going mental when schoolmates call his mum a ho (that actually happens). Simon Pegg’s Scotty is the comic relief, and so runs the risk of being the Jar Jar Binks of the piece – for our money, he needs to lose the green sidekick and tone down the slapstick, but otherwise fine.
Style is the area where Abrams defers to the original, with the shinier members of Starfleet resembling a colourful choir from the Sixties, emphasising a utopian break with the futuristic space suits of the initial scenes, and the griminess of Earth’s lesser citizens. The security guards are huge in the way that Deep Space Nine imagined they were in Trials And Tribble-ations, with bruiser Sixties hairdos complete with the suggestion of Bryllcreme. It’s as if the Sixties are just happening for the military – as if someone decided that bright colours go well with the Federation’s mission to foxtrot to the final frontier.
Anything would look good coming after Nemesis, but this is ruddy good fun. If only it could all be as good as the opening scene.